Charging Residential Air Conditioning
- by R.D. Holder
Different types of metering devices have different ways of charging. A
Thermostatic Expansion Valve (TXV) is charged to the sub-cooling of the
liquid line leaving the condenser. A fixed orifice is charged to the
superheat of the suction line leaving the evaporator. To understand why
this is, it requires an understanding of the physical properties of the
refrigeration cycle. The four main components of the refrigeration cycle
include:
Compressor
Condenser
Metering Devices
Evaporator
These four components are divided into sections and explained in depth
as follows.
Compressor
The Compressor compresses a low-pressure superheated gas into a
high-pressure superheated gas. If the suction gas is not superheated,
the compressor can be damaged. The compressor pulls the refrigerant out
of the evaporator and pushes it though a condenser. The act of
compression is performed by any one of the following six types of
compressors: a reciprocating piston, rotary, scroll, screw, centrifugal,
and sonic compressors. Of the six, the reciprocating and scroll
compressors are the two most frequently found in a residential air
conditioning system.
The mass flow rate produced by a compressor is equal to the mass of the
suction gas pulled in by the compressor. The compressor’s out put is
equally only to its intake because the mass flow must be equal. The
process of compression, through mass flow, raises the temperature and
pressure of the refrigerant. The result of the temperature increase is
superheat. Pressure and temperature of the refrigerant must be higher
than the condensing temperature. The refrigerant temperature must be
higher so heat can flow into the condensing medium. This process
explains the necessary relationship between the increased pressure and
the rise in temperature. If the pressure and temperature is not
increased through compression, there is no heat transferred from the
refrigerant to the condensing medium. The compressor has a maximum inlet
temperature of about 70 degrees F and outlet of about 225 degrees F.
Inlet refrigerant vapor cools the compressor motor.
De-superheating (heat leaving the refrigerant gas) of refrigerant begins
as it is discharged. From a compressor and pushed into a condenser.
Condenser
The condenser removes heat and changes a high-pressure vapor into a
high-pressure liquid. As the superheated (high-pressure) gas is pushed
into the condenser, it is desuperheated, that is the temperature is
reduced to saturated pressure-temperature.
The refrigerant does not start to change state until the temperature
reaches saturated pressure-temperature. The only variable that can
change the temperature is a pressure change.
(See table 1) At saturation
pressure-temperature point, the change of state becomes latent heat
(invisible or hidden heat). Latent heat is a lack of rise or fall of
temperature during a change of state (saturation). When the temperature
does not rise or fall it is at saturation and the change of state
process begins. Refrigerant continues to change state at one
pressure-temperature. At the change of state the refrigerant liquid and
vapor are at the same temperature. This is defined as equilibrium
contact. The temperatures of the liquid and vapors will stay the same
until the temperature of the refrigerant starts to drop. Temperature of
the refrigerant start to drop once 98% to 99% of the refrigerant becomes
a liquid. This is called sub-cooling. Sub-cooling is a temperature below
saturated pressure-temperature.
(See table 1) Sub-cooling is a
measurement of how much liquid is in the condenser. In air conditioning,
it is important to measure sub-cooling because the longer the liquid
stays in the condenser, the greater the sensible (visible) heat loss.
Low sub-cooling means that a condenser is empty. High sub-cooling means
that a condenser is full. Over filling a system increases, pressure due
to the liquid filling of a condenser that shows up as high sub-cooling.
To move the refrigerant from condenser to the liquid line, it must be
pushed down the liquid line to a metering device. If a pressure drop
occurs in the liquid line and the refrigerant has no sub-cooling, the
refrigerant will start to re-vaporize (change state from a liquid to a
vapor) before reaching the metering devise.
Refrigerant –22 (Table 1)
Liquid line
Saturated temperate - Temperature = sub-cooling
200 psig = 101 degrees - 96 degrees = 5 degrees
210 psig = 105 degrees - 90 degrees = 15 degrees
240 psig = 114 degrees - 98 degrees = 16 degrees
Metering Devices
A metering device is a pressure drop point, which has two jobs:
(1) Holds refrigerant back in a condenser and
(2) Feeds refrigerant into the evaporator.
When high-pressure liquid enters a metering device, pressure starts to
drop, as the temperature remains the same until it reaches saturation
pressure-temperature. At this time both the pressure and temperature
continues to drop to evaporator pressure-temperature.
(See table 2)
Low-pressure liquid that is leaving the metering device is boiling at
saturated pressure-temperature. The process of a refrigerant changing
its state (from a liquid to a vapor) in the metering device is called
flash gas. Flash gas is what cools the refrigerant liquid in the
metering device. A system with no sub-cooling has more gas that is
flashed and less capacity.
Evaporators
The refrigerant enters the evaporator as a boiling low-pressure liquid
at saturated pressure-temperature. It continues to boil at one
temperature as long as the pressure remains the same. If there is not a
pressure change in the evaporator, there will not be a temperature
change in the refrigerant changing state. At saturation, refrigerant
absorbs latent heat, which is a change of state heat. The refrigerant
changes state at one temperature (for any one pressure) from the
beginning of the evaporator until the entire liquid refrigerant has
become a vapor. The only variable that can change a temperature is a
pressure change. If a temperature change occurs a pressure change
occurs. In latent heat, the liquid and vapor are at the same temperature
due to equilibrium contact. When heat is added to the gas, past
saturation pressure-temperature, it is called superheat. (See Table 2)
Superheat is an indication of how full the evaporator is of liquid
refrigerant. High superheat means the evaporator is empty. Low superheat
means the evaporator is full. There have been reports that liquid
refrigerant can still be boiling with 2 degrees of superheat. Superheat
should never be observed below 4 degrees or a compressor failure may
occur. The superheat gas is pulled into the compressor were it starts
the cycle again.
Refrigerant –22 (Table 2)
Suction Line
Saturated temperate - Temperature =
58 psig = 32 degrees - 44 degrees = 12 degrees
64 psig = 37 degrees - 47 degrees = 10 degrees
70 psig = 41 degrees - 50 degrees = 9 degrees
Charging Methods
Before charging of a residential air conditioning system, two
temperatures must be recorded:
(1) Condensing air inlet
dry bulb temperature.
(2) Evaporator air inlet
wet bulb temperature.
Wet bulb temperature is a measurement of the heat contained within air.
Air may have many different wet bulb temperatures for one dry bulb
temperature, depending on relative humidity of the air.
Different types of metering devices have different ways of charging.
Thermostatic Expansion Valve R-22
A/C with a Thermostatic Expansion Valve (TXV) is charged to the
sub-cooling of the liquid line leaving the condenser because the
superheat is fixed. The superheat is fixed at 8 to 12 degrees in most
residential air conditioning systems. Sub-cooling is the amount of
liquid held back in the condenser. This allows the liquid to give up
more heat, below saturated pressure- temperature. For every one degree
of sub-cooling at the same condensing pressure, capacity will increase
0.5 percent. Increasing sub-cooling with an increase of discharge
pressure and compression ratio, decrease capacity. Add 5 degrees of
sub-cooling for every 30 feet of liquid line lift.
To Measure Sub-cooling:
Obtain refrigerant saturation pressure-temperature. Take a pressure
reading of the liquid line leaving the condenser. Refrigerant saturation
temperature is the pressure-temperature when the refrigerant is turning
from a high-pressure vapor into a high-pressure liquid (giving up heat).
At saturation pressure-temperature, both liquid and vapor are at the
same temperature.
(1) Convert pressure to temperature with a pressure temperature chart.
(2) Take a temperature reading at the leaving liquid line of the
condenser.
Compare both, the saturated temperature and leaving liquid line
temperature. Subtracting one from the other, the difference is the
amount the refrigerant has cooled past saturated temperature. This is
sub-cooling.
(See table 1)
This four-step procedure is known as sub-cooling. Manufacturers should
be able to identify the amounts of sub-cooling they have designed into a
system. A low charge will give a low sub-cooling. An overcharge will
give a high sub-cooling along with a high compression ratio. Do not
worry about a few bubbles in the sight glass. Sight glasses will not
always be clear with a full charge. The zeotropes refrigerant group is
known for their fractionation. It is possible to never have a clear
sight glass. To determine what the sub-cooling should be in a system
see
table 3.
Sub-cooling for A/C with TXV
R-22 (Table 3)
Evaporator Inlet Air Temperature Fahrenheit Wet Bulb
57 59 61 63 65 67 69 71 73
Outside Air
Temperature DB
75 31 30 29 27 25 23 21 19 17
80 30 29 26 24 23 21 19 17 15
85 28 27 24 22 21 19 18 16 14
90 27 25 22 20 19 17 16 14 12
95 25 23 20 19 17 15 13 11 9
100 23 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6
105 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4
110 18 15 13 11 9 7 5 3 1
115 15 13 11 9 7 5 3 1 0
Fixed Orifice R-22
A/C with a fixed orifice is charged to the superheat of the suction line
leaving the evaporator. Superheat is the gas temperature above the
saturated temperature.
Superheat can be split into two types of heat:
(1) Superheat of the evaporators and
(2) Total superheat entering the compressor.
The evaporators superheat must be figured at the evaporator outlet not
at the compressor inlet. Total superheat is figured at the compressor
inlet.
To Measure Evaporator Superheat:
Take a pressure reading of the suction line-leaving evaporator to get
refrigerant saturation pressure-temperature. Refrigerant saturation
temperature is the pressure-temperature when the refrigerant is turning
from a low-pressure liquid to a low-pressure vapor (absorbing heat). At
saturation pressure-temperature, both liquid and vapor are at the same
temperature.
Convert pressure to temperature with a pressure temperature chart. If
reading is obtained at the compressor, not at the evaporator leaving
line, you may have to add a few pounds of pressure due to pressure drop
in the suction line.
Take a temperature reading at the leaving suction line of the
evaporator.
Compare both, the saturated temperature and the leaving suction line
temperature. Subtracting one from the other, the difference is the
amount the refrigerant gas has heated past saturated temperature. This
is superheat.
(See table 2)
This four-step procedure is known as superheat. Manufacturers should be
able to identify the amounts of superheat they have designed into a
system. A low charge will give a high superheat. An overcharge will give
a low superheat along with a higher compression ratio. To determine what
superheat in a system should be
see table 4.
Superheat for A/C with fixed Orifice
R-22 (Table 4)
Evaporator Inlet Air Temperature Fahrenheit Wet Bulb
Outside Air
Temperature DB
60 13 17 18 20 24 26 28 30 33 36 39
65 11 13 15 17 18 22 25 28 30 33 36
70 8 11 12 14 16 18 22 25 28 30 33
75 5 7 10 12 14 16 18 23 26 28 30
80 4 6 8 12 14 16 18 23 27 28
85 4 6 8 12 14 17 20 25 27
90 4 6 9 12 15 18 22 25
95 4 7 11 13 16 20 23
100 5 8 11 14 18 20
105 4 6 8 12 15 19
110 5 7 11 14 18
115 5 8 13 16
Refrigeration
The use of sight glass for charging is common in refrigeration. It is
better to charge a system first by measuring the operating condition
(discharge and suction pressures, suction line temperature, compressor
amps, super heat, sub-cooling and coils temperature differential) before
using the liquid line sight glass. If the sight glass is close to the
exit of the condenser or if there is very little sub-cooling at the
sight glass, bubbles may be present even when the system is properly
charged. If a system is charged to full sight glass, overcharging may be
the result, decreasing efficiency.
Note: Follow the manufacturer recommendation for superheat and
sub-cooling.
A Thermostatic Expansion Valve (TXV) is designed to maintain a constant
superheat. Over charging a TXV will rise sub-cooling, increases system
pressures, and decreases system efficiency. Under charging a TXV will
decrease sub-cooling, increases superheat, decrease system capacity, and
lower refrigerant velocity leaving oil in the evaporator. An Automatic
Expansion Valve (AXV) is a constant evaporator pressure valve and not
normally used in A/C. A fixed orifices is the simplest metering devise
made and the most critical to charge. Over charging fixed orifices will
lower superheat, increase pressures, decrease efficiency, and flood the
compressor with liquid refrigerant. Under charging the fixed orifices
will raise superheat, lower pressure, lower capacity and lower
refrigerant velocity leaving oil in the evaporator. Always refer to the
manufacturer recommendations on charging fixed orifices.
The process of charging to superheat and sub-cooling improves an air
conditioning systems' efficiency, capacity and lessens equipment
failures. Always let system stabilize 10 to 20 minutes after adjusting
the charge, this takes time but improves the accuracy.
Remember when charging refrigerants all superheat and sub-cooling
adjustments must be checked and recorded. The procedure of recording
adjustments is called Baselining. This procedure not only saves time,
money and aggravation but it is a sign of a professional.
Roger D. Holder, CM, BSME, is a member of the
Southern San Joaquin Chapter in Bakersfield, Calif. He also is a
refrigeration and air conditioning specialist at National Technical
Transfer Inc., Englewood, CO 80155